Guide
Kaolin vs French Green Clay vs Multani Mitti: Which Clay Suits Your Skin?
White kaolin is the mild clay for normal, dry or easily tight skin. French green clay and Multani Mitti are for oily skin and a shiny T-zone. Here is how the three compare, and where bentonite fits.
The short answer: White kaolin is the mild clay, for normal, combination, dry or easily tight skin. French green clay and Multani Mitti take up more oil and suit oily skin and a shiny T-zone. All three are thin masks for 5–10 minutes at most, rinsed before they crack.
Which clay is best for the face?
The one that matches how oily your skin is. A clay mask takes up oil at the surface while it is wet and setting. The oilier your skin, the more of that you want, and the drier your skin, the less.
- Oily skin or a shiny T-zone: French green clay or Multani Mitti.
- Combination skin: white kaolin over the whole face, or French green clay on the T-zone only.
- Normal, dry, sensitive or mature skin that feels tight easily: white kaolin.
The three clays at a glance
Here is how they compare, side by side.
| White kaolin | French green clay | Multani Mitti | |
|---|---|---|---|
| What it is | A white, kaolinite-rich clay | Montmorillonite, a green clay | Fuller's earth, a natural mix of clay minerals |
| Oil uptake | Lower | Higher | Higher |
| Feel as it sets | Light, with little tightness | Noticeably tight | Noticeably tight |
| Best for | Normal, combination, dry or easily tight skin | Oily and combination skin | Oily skin |
| For one face mask | 1–2 teaspoons | 1 teaspoon | 1–2 teaspoons |
| Time on the skin | 5–10 minutes at most | 5–10 minutes at most | 5–10 minutes at most |
| On dry or reactive skin | 3–5 minutes | 3–5 minutes, oily areas only | 3–5 minutes |
| How often | Once a week, up to twice for oily skin | Once a week, up to twice for oily skin | Once a week, up to twice for oily skin |
French green clay and Multani Mitti are not ranked against each other here. Both take up more oil than kaolin, and which you prefer comes down to feel and to how your skin gets on with each.
Choose white kaolin if…
You want the mildest clay mask.
- Your skin is normal, combination or on the dry side.
- Your skin feels tight easily, or you are new to clay masks.
- You dislike the strong tightening feel of other clays.
- You want a clean, fresh finish more than the most oil removal.
How to use kaolin clay on your face has the method, and the kaolin clay page has more about the clay.
Choose French green clay if…
Oil and shine are your main concern.
- Your skin is oily, or your T-zone gets greasy during the day.
- Your skin already gets on well with clay masks.
- You want to mask the forehead, nose and chin only and leave your cheeks bare.
How to use French green clay on your face has the method, and there is more on the French green clay page.
Choose Multani Mitti if…
You have oily skin and want the traditional clay for it.
- Your skin is oily and stays comfortable after a clay mask.
- You want the fuller's earth mask long used in South Asian skincare.
How to use Multani Mitti on your face has the method, and there is more on the Multani Mitti page.
Which is better for your skin, bentonite or kaolin?
Kaolin for normal, dry, sensitive and combination skin; bentonite for very oily skin. Bentonite swells strongly in water and makes a thick paste that pulls tight as it dries, so it takes up oil strongly and can be drying. Kaolin doesn't swell, so its paste is lighter and milder on the skin.
Spierb doesn't sell bentonite. In this range, French green clay and Multani Mitti are the clays for oilier skin, and white kaolin is the mild one.
Can you use two clays together?
Yes. White kaolin is mixed with French green clay or with Multani Mitti to make a milder mask for combination skin. Those recipes are in the Complete Mixing and Application Guide that comes with your pack.
French green clay and Multani Mitti are both strong on oil, so they are used on separate days, not in the same mask and not on back-to-back days.
Frequently Asked Questions
What can I use instead of kaolin clay?
For oily skin, Multani Mitti or French green clay, which take up more oil. For a mask without clay, aloe vera powder or orange peel powder.
What is the best clay for beginners?
White kaolin. It is the mildest of the three, so it is the easiest place to start. Begin with a thin layer for 3–5 minutes and moisturise afterwards.
Which clay mask is best for mature skin?
Usually white kaolin, because it is less drying. Keep the layer thin, rinse after 5–10 minutes at most and moisturise. A clay mask is about oil and a fresh finish; it isn't an anti-ageing treatment.
How do French green clay and bentonite differ?
They are related. Spierb French Green Clay is montmorillonite, the mineral that most bentonite is largely made of, but bentonite usually swells far more and feels much tighter on the skin. The French green clay page explains the difference.
Clay or charcoal: which is better for oily skin?
They work best together. A pinch of activated charcoal in a clay base makes a more usable mask than charcoal alone. How to make an activated charcoal face mask has the recipe.
Do clay masks pull out blackheads?
They take up oil at the surface, which can make pores look less noticeable for a while. Do clay masks remove blackheads? explains what they can and can't do.
