Do Clay and Charcoal Masks Remove Blackheads? What They Really Do for Oil and Pores

Clay and charcoal masks take up oil at the surface, so skin looks less shiny and pores less noticeable for a while. They don't pull blackheads out. Here is what is going on, and what to do.

The short answer: Not in the way the name suggests. A clay or charcoal mask takes up oil and loose residue at the surface, so skin looks less shiny and pores look less noticeable for a while. It doesn't pull blackheads out of the pore.

Do clay masks pull out blackheads?

No. A clay mask cleans up the surface around a blackhead; it doesn't remove the blackhead itself. While the mask is wet and setting, the clay takes up oil sitting on the skin and around the opening of each pore. When you rinse, that oil goes with it.

The result is real and you can see it straight away: a matte finish, a cleaner-looking nose and chin, and pores that stand out less. It is a surface effect, and it lasts until your skin's oil builds up again later in the day.

What is a blackhead?

A blackhead is a pore plugged with a mix of skin oil and dead skin cells. The plug sits inside the pore, and its top turns dark where it meets the air. The colour isn't dirt, and it isn't a sign of skin that hasn't been washed properly.

That is why a mask can't lift it out. The mask sits on top of the skin for 5–10 minutes, and the plug is held inside the pore.

Does charcoal really remove blackheads?

No. Charcoal behaves like clay here: it picks up oil it touches at the surface. Activated charcoal has a very porous structure, so oil and residue cling to it and rinse away with the mask. In a home-made mask it is a pinch stirred into a clay base, and the clay does most of the work.

Do clay and charcoal masks clean or shrink pores?

They leave the surface cleaner, and pores can look smaller for a few hours. They don't change the size of a pore. Pores don't open and close, and steam or warm water doesn't open them. How large they look depends mostly on your skin and how much oil it makes. Less oil at the surface makes them less noticeable, which is the honest reason a clay mask improves the look of a shiny nose.

Where does the belief come from?

Mostly from what a drying mask looks like, and from peel-off strips.

  • Dots on the mask. As a clay mask dries, small darker dots often appear over the nose and chin. They are spots where the clay has soaked up oil at the surface. They are not blackheads coming out.
  • Peel-off masks and strips. These are a different kind of product. A sticky film grips the skin and lifts some surface material when you peel it away. That comes from the film, not from charcoal or clay.
  • "Draws out impurities." Clay and charcoal do draw up oil, but only what they are in contact with. They don't pull anything through the skin, and there are no toxins involved.

What should you do?

Use a mask for what it does well, and be kind to your skin while you do it.

  1. Use a clay or charcoal mask about once a week on oily areas for a cleaner, less shiny look. Rinse it off before it dries hard, and moisturise afterwards.
  2. Leave longer times, thicker layers and daily masks alone. They dry the skin without reaching the blackheads.
  3. If blackheads bother you, a pharmacist or dermatologist can suggest skincare made for them.

The methods are here: how to use kaolin clay on your face, how to use French green clay on your face and how to make an activated charcoal face mask.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is kaolin clay good for pimples?

Kaolin suits oily, blemish-prone skin as a short mask because it takes up surface oil. It isn't a treatment for spots, and it shouldn't go on broken, picked or inflamed skin. For acne that is painful or doesn't settle, speak to a GP or pharmacist.

Do clay or charcoal masks pull out toxins?

No. They take up oil and loose residue at the surface of the skin. Nothing is drawn out from inside the body, and a mask cracking as it dries is not a sign of toxins leaving.

Can a charcoal peel-off mask remove blackheads?

A peel-off mask is a different product from a charcoal and clay mask. Its sticky film can lift some material from the surface, which is where the visible result comes from. Charcoal powder mixed into clay doesn't work that way.

Is there a mask that actually pulls out blackheads?

No rinse-off mask pulls blackheads out of the pore, deep ones least of all. A clay mask leaves the area looking cleaner. For the blackheads themselves, ask a pharmacist or dermatologist.

Which clay is best for oily, blackhead-prone skin?

French green clay takes up the most oil, and white kaolin is the milder of the two. Kaolin clay vs French green clay vs Multani Mitti compares them.

Related reading

Guides Kaolin vs French Green Clay vs Multani Mitti: Which Clay Suits Your Skin? White kaolin is the mild clay for normal, dry or easily tight skin. French green clay and Multani Mitti are... How-to How to Use Kaolin Clay on Your Face: A Simple Clay Mask, Step by Step A kaolin clay mask takes about 15 minutes. Here is how much clay and water to use, how long to leave it on,... How-to How to Use French Green Clay on Your Face: The Mask for Oily and Combination Skin A French green clay mask takes about 15 minutes. Here is how to mix it, how thin to spread it, when to rins...